9 Best Earl Grey Tea Options Featured
|

9 Best Earl Grey Tea Options (Organic & Flavorful)

Some of the links are affiliate links. I may receive a commission for purchases you make at no extra cost to you.

Are you an Earl Grey lover but feeling overwhelmed by the sheer number of Earl Grey options out there?

Let’s unravel the magic behind this iconic tea, where robust black tea meets zesty bergamot charm.

I’ve handpicked only organic teas for this list because, let’s face it, we all want the purest sip without any chemical nasties. Plus, going organic means supporting sustainable farming practices and a healthier planet.

Ready to step into the world of Earl Grey teas? Let’s dive in!

What Is the Best Earl Grey Tea?

Best Loose Leaf: Art of Tea: Earl Grey Crème Tea

Best with vanilla hints: The Republic of Tea: Earl Greyer Vanilla Black Tea Bags

Best Aged: Numi Organic Aged Earl Grey

Best tea bags: FGO Organic Earl Grey Black Tea

Best with citrus hints: Teatulia Organic Earl Grey Tea Bags

Here is the list of all nine best Earl Grey teas.

1. Art Of Tea: Earl Grey Crème Tea

Earl Grey Crème Tea

Why I Like It

Upon opening the package of Art of Tea’s Earl Grey Crème, the aroma was notably pleasant. I’ve tried various brands before, and while many have been enjoyable, this one had a distinct charm. The taste is balanced and not overpowering, making it a good choice for my morning or afternoon iced tea sessions. Some prefer it with a touch of honey or half-and-half, while others, like me, find it just right on its own. It’s a wonderful Earl Grey tea that has found its place in my tea collection.

About The Brand

Art of Tea stands out for its exceptional Earl Grey Crème and its commitment to quality across all its Earl Grey blends. The brand has consistently impressed me with the caliber of its teas. Purchasing in bulk from them has been a delightful way to savor high-quality tea at a more affordable cost per cup.

Price

The Earl Grey Crème Tea is priced at $20.00 USD. For the unique and enchanting flavor experience it offers, it’s worth every penny.

2. FGO Organic Earl Grey Black Tea

FGO Organic Earl Grey Black Tea

Why I Like It

I’ve been sipping on the FGO Organic Earl Grey Black Tea for a while now, and I must say, it’s become one of my favorites. The quality is top-notch, and knowing it’s organic gives me peace of mind. The aroma is inviting, and the semi-sweet taste is just right for my palate. I don’t even need to add any sweeteners; a dash of date syrup does the trick if I’m in the mood. And the eco-conscious tea bags? That’s a cherry on top for me, as I’m always looking for ways to make sustainable choices.

About The Brand

FGO isn’t just another brand for me. Their focus on organic products speaks volumes about their commitment. Their Earl Grey Black Tea is a clear reflection of their dedication to quality and the environment.s

Price

Priced at $14.99 for a pack of 20 Earl Grey tea bags, it offers value for money, especially considering its organic certification and the quality it brings to the table.

3. 20 Leaves Earl Grey Loose Leaf Black Tea

20 Leaves Earl Grey Loose Leaf

Why I Like It

I’ve recently tried the Earl Grey Loose Leaf Black Tea, and it’s been a delightful experience. The freshness of the tea is evident right from the moment I opened the pouch. The aroma is captivating, with a hint of maltiness and faint fruity notes. Drinking it has been a pleasure; the taste is typically Assam but uniquely simple. What I particularly appreciate is the low astringency, even when brewed strong. This tea has become my morning ritual, especially when I want a strong black tea taste that pairs well with oat milk. The only thing I wished for was a bit more bite, which I usually expect from an Assam. But overall, it’s been a satisfying experience.

About The Brand

The brand has done a commendable job in ensuring the quality of the tea. The packaging is simple, focusing more on preserving the freshness and quality of the tea leaves. The compact balls of dried leaves are a testament to the care taken during processing.

Price

A one-pound ouch costs $21.99

4. NUMI Organic Aged Earl Grey Tea

Numi Organic Aged Earl Grey Tea

Numi Organic Aged Earl Grey Tea, 16 Ounce Pouch, Loose Leaf Black Tea With Bergamot

Why I Like It

The freshness of this tea is undeniable, and the aroma is simply captivating. It reminds me of the delicate golden tips of tea leaves, infused with the essence of spring honey. The taste is a delightful earl grey blend of mild and light flavors, with a slightly toasty note that I’ve come to adore. I’ve tried brewing it both hot and cold, and it never disappoints. The flavor is consistent, and the quality is evident in every sip. I’ve even introduced it to my friends and family, and they’ve all been equally impressed.

About The Brand

Numi has always stood out for its commitment to quality. Their teas are fresh, and the flavors are authentic. The packaging ensures that the tea remains sealed tight, preserving its aroma and freshness. It’s no wonder that Numi has become a household name for many tea enthusiasts like me.

Price

The tea comes in a 16 16-ounce pouch, and it’s good for brewing up to 200 cups.

5. The Republic of Tea: Earl Greyer Vanilla Black Tea Bags

Earl Greyer Vanilla Black Tea Bags

Why I Like It

The Earl Greyer Vanilla Black Tea from The Republic of Tea has quickly become a cherished part of my daily routine. The moment I opened the tin, I was greeted with a delightful aroma that hinted at the rich flavors within. This tea is a wonderful blend of the classic Earl Grey with a hint of vanilla, making it a perfect afternoon treat. The traditional British tea with the oil of bergamot is beautifully paired with an exotic vanilla flavor, offering an intriguing finish. I’ve found it to be a delightful brew, whether I’m enjoying it with some sweet baked goods or sipping it on its own. It’s versatile, too – perfect with or without milk and sugar.

About The Brand

The Republic of Tea stands out for its dedication to quality and authenticity. Their teas are fresh, and the flavors are genuine. The packaging is designed to preserve the tea’s freshness and aroma, making every cup a delightful experience.

Price and Quantity

The tea is priced at $14.50 and comes in a tin containing 50 tea bags. Given the quality and the unique flavor profile, I find it to be a worthy purchase.

6. Teatulia Organic Earl Grey Tea Bags

Teatulia Organic Earl Grey Tea_

Why I Like It

I adore Teatulia’s Organic Earl Grey Tea for its rich black tea flavor, perfectly accented by bright bergamot notes. Its natural sweetness means no added sugar for me, and the aroma is simply captivating. Every sip is a delightful experience, making it one of my top choices for an Earl Grey tea bag version. The fact that it’s sustainably grown in Bangladesh adds to its appeal, making me feel good about my choice both in terms of flavor and ethics.

About The Brand

Teatulia stands out not just for its delicious teas but also for its commitment to ethical sourcing and sustainability. They are the only brand that emphasizes cultivating both the land and the quality of life at every step of their process. Their teas reflect their deep connection to the land, delivering organic options with distinctly nuanced flavors. Furthermore, their dedication to the environment is evident in their packaging, with 91% being compostable and recyclable, and they aim to achieve 100% by 2024.

Price

A bag with 90 square tea bags is currently $19.95, which equates to 22 cents per tea bag.

7. Choice Organics

Choice Organics - Organic Earl Grey Tea

Why I Like It

Having tried the Choice Organic Teas Black Tea, I appreciate its robust flavor and aromatic scent. Based on the reviews on Amazon, it’s clear that this tea stands out for many. The organic certification adds an extra layer of assurance for me, knowing I’m sipping on something pure.

About The Brand:

What draws me to Choice Organic Teas is not just the quality of their brews but also their values. Every cup is a testament to their commitment to sustainability and intentionality. They’re not just about great teas; they’re about a lifestyle that values both personal well-being and the environment.

Price

The Choice Organic Teas Black Tea is priced around $13 for a 3-pack, with each pack containing 16 tea bags.

8. Rishi Tea Lavender Earl Grey

Rishi Tea Earl Grey Lavender Loose Leaf Herbal Tea

Why I Like It

The Rishi Earl Grey Lavender tea offers a unique and delightful flavor profile that stands out. The blend of Earl Grey with a hint of lavender provides a refreshing twist to the classic taste. Many reviewers have praised its robust flavor, aromatic scent, and the perfect balance of bergamot and lavender. The whole leaf quality ensures a fresh and authentic taste, and the tea’s aroma is both inviting and calming.

About The Brand

Rishi Tea is known for its commitment to quality and authenticity. Their teas are fresh, and the flavors are genuine. The brand has garnered a loyal following of tea enthusiasts who appreciate the care and expertise that goes into every blend. The organic certification of this tea adds an extra layer of assurance, emphasizing the brand’s dedication to both quality and sustainability.

Price

Priced at $38 for one pound, this Earl Grey tea is priced higher than some other teas, but given its organic certification, whole-leaf quality, and unique flavor profile, many find it to be a worthy investment in their tea experience.

9. U.S. Wellness Naturals Store Earl Grey Tea

US Wellness Naturals Earl Grey Tea

Why I Like It

I’ve been enjoying this Earl Grey Tea for its floral and citrusy notes. The blend is refreshing and invigorating, and the aroma is simply captivating. What stands out for me is its robust flavor, perfectly balanced with bergamot and other natural flavors. Knowing it’s organic gives me peace of mind, ensuring I’m sipping on something pure and of high quality. It’s no surprise to me that many others have labeled it as one of the best Earl Grey teas they’ve tried.

About The Brand

This brand has impressed me with its dedication to delivering top-notch, organic teas. The positive feedback it has garnered on Amazon is a testament to its commitment to excellence and the satisfaction of its tea enthusiasts like me.

Price

The 8 oz bag is currently $13.99 on Amazon.

What Is Earl Grey Tea?

Earl Grey tea is a black tea blend, distinctively flavored with the oil from the rind of a bergamot orange. This citrus fruit, native to Italy, imparts a unique aromatic scent and flavor to the tea. Named after Charles Grey, the 2nd Earl Grey and British Prime Minister in the 1830s, legend has it that the blend was gifted to him after a diplomatic mission to China. Today, Earl Grey remains one of the most recognized flavored teas in the world, loved for its bright, citrusy notes and deep black tea base.

How I Tested Each Tea

Tea tasting is both an art and a science. To ensure fairness and consistency in my evaluations, I followed a systematic approach:

  • Water Temperature & Quality: I used fresh, filtered water for each brew and ensured it was heated to the optimal temperature for black tea, which is typically between 200°F to 212°F.
  • Steeping Time: To extract the true essence of each tea, I adhered to the recommended steeping time, usually between 3 to 5 minutes. This ensured that the tea was neither too weak nor overly bitter.
  • Leaf-to-Water Ratio: I used about one teaspoon of loose leaf tea (or one tea bag) for every 8 ounces of water. This standard measure provided a balanced brew.
  • Aroma Assessment: Before tasting, I took a moment to inhale the aroma of the brewed tea. The scent often provides hints about the flavor profile and quality of the tea.
  • Taste Test: I sipped each tea without any additives first to assess its natural flavor. Later, I experimented with a dash of milk or a hint of sweetener to see how the flavor profile changed.
  • Mouthfeel & Aftertaste: A good tea isn’t just about the initial taste. I paid attention to the texture of the tea in my mouth and the lingering aftertaste, noting any astringency or smoothness.
  • Visual Appeal: The color of the brewed tea can offer insights into its quality and strength. I observed the hue of each brew, looking for a clear, vibrant color.

The Allure of Earl Grey

Earl Grey is more than just a tea; it’s an experience. But what makes it so universally loved?

  • A Global Affair: While its roots trace back to England, the key ingredient, bergamot, hails from sunny Italy. This blend of British and Italian influences creates a comforting and exotic tea.
  • A Sip of History: Every cup of Earl Grey whispers tales from the past. Named after a British Prime Minister, it’s a tea that has graced royal tables and been a part of pivotal moments in history.
  • Beyond the Brew: Earl Grey’s influence isn’t limited to the teapot. Its unique flavor profile has inspired chefs and bakers worldwide, leading to creations like Earl Grey macarons, chocolates, and even cocktails!

A Toast To Timeless Tea

As we wrap up our tea journey, I’m reminded of cozy afternoons, a book in one hand and a cup of Earl Grey in the other. Each brand on this list has its unique charm, but they all share a commitment to organic quality. It’s not just about taste; it’s about the stories, the history, and the moments we create with every sip. So, the next time you brew a cup, take a moment to savor its rich legacy and the love that goes into producing every leaf. Here’s to many more tea-filled days ahead!


FAQs

Is Earl Grey tea caffeinated?

Yes, being a black tea blend, Earl Grey contains caffeine, though the amount can vary based on the brand and brewing time.

Can I drink Earl Grey tea daily?

Absolutely! Many people enjoy Earl Grey as their daily tea. However, like all caffeinated beverages, it’s essential to consume in moderation.

What pairs well with Earl Grey tea?

Earl Grey pairs beautifully with pastries, especially those with citrus notes. Lemon tarts, orange scones, or even simple butter cookies complement the tea’s flavor.

Why is it called Earl Grey?

The tea is named after Charles Grey, the 2nd Earl Grey, the British Prime Minister in the 1830s. Legend suggests the blend was gifted to him after a diplomatic mission to China.

Does Earl Grey tea have health benefits?

Like other black teas, Earl Grey has antioxidants that can help improve heart health and digestion and provide a modest energy boost due to its caffeine content. The bergamot oil is also believed to have calming properties.